Does Insurance Cover a Keyed Car? How to Claim and When to Pay Yourself
Does insurance cover a keyed car?
Yes, if your policy has comprehensive cover. Keying is vandalism, not a collision, and comprehensive includes vandalism in Canada and the U.S. In Canada, specified perils or all perils cover can also pay. You pay your deductible first and the insurer pays the rest, so compare the repair estimate with your deductible before you claim.
Sources, as of 2026
Cover and claim rules come from the Insurance Bureau of Canada (IBC), the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, ICBC (British Columbia) and Manitoba Public Insurance (MPI), the mischief offence from section 430 of the Criminal Code of Canada, and the U.S. cover rules from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) and the Insurance Information Institute. The repair price ranges, the buffing and rust notes and the U.S. rate effect come from one U.S. insurance price guide (2026); those ranges are U.S. prices in USD, not Canadian prices. Confirm your cover and claim steps with your insurer, ICBC, MPI or your state insurance department.
Which insurance cover pays for a keyed car
| Cover | Pays for keying? | What to know |
|---|---|---|
| Collision (Canada) | No | Keying is vandalism, not a collision. In Canada, vandalism damage is paid only under one of the three covers below. |
| Comprehensive (Canada) | Yes | It covers all perils except three: a collision, an upset of the car, and theft by someone who lives with you or works on your car. Vandal damage is one of its examples. |
| Specified perils or all perils (Canada) | Can pay | The other two covers that can pay for vandalism. Read the perils that your policy names. |
| ICBC Comprehensive (British Columbia) | Yes | Vandalism claims are covered, and ICBC names scratches as one type of vandalism damage. |
| Comprehensive (U.S.) | Yes | Pays for theft, or for damage that a collision with another car or object did not cause. Vandalism is on its list of covered events. |
What to do when you find your car keyed
- 1Photograph the scratches and note when and where
Take close and wide photos of each scratch, and write down the date, the time and the place where you found the damage. Photos and notes made at the scene are important evidence for an insurance claim.
- 2Report it to the police, also when you do not know who did it
In Canada, a report to the police gives you official police documentation of the damage. In Manitoba, a police report is required for a vandalism claim: MPI prefers that you call the police before you open the claim, so that you can give the report number at once. If you cannot, you can add the number to the claim later. In the U.S., ask your local police how to file a vandalism report.
- 3Get estimates from a few body shops
Ask a few body shops to price the repair, and keep each estimate in writing. If your insurer names a shop, read whether you must use the insurer's preferred shop before you agree.
- 4Open the claim with your insurer
Contact your insurer or your provincial insurer, and give it the photos, the written estimates and the police report number.
Did you find what you were looking for?
Deductible on a keyed-car claim: a worked example in CAD
Take a CAD 900 repair estimate and a CAD 500 deductible (sample values: use your own). The claim pays CAD 400 (900 − 500), and you pay CAD 500. In British Columbia, you pay your deductible to the shop when the repairs are done.
Worked example: U.S. scratch repair prices against a sample deductible (USD, 2026)
| Scratch depth | Repair price, U.S. guide, 2026 | Claim pays with a USD 500 deductible (sample) | Claim pays with a USD 1,000 deductible (sample) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clear coat only | USD 150 to 300 | USD 0 (the repair costs less than the deductible) | USD 0 |
| Into the colour layer | USD 400 to 1,000 | USD 0 to 500 (1,000 − 500 = 500) | USD 0 |
| Down to primer, bare metal or plastic | USD 800 to 1,500 | USD 300 to 1,000 (800 − 500 = 300; 1,500 − 500 = 1,000) | USD 0 to 500 (1,500 − 1,000 = 500) |
Claim or pay yourself: decide by the estimate
Will a keyed-car claim raise your insurance rates?
In Canada, a claim may raise your premium in the future or when you renew your policy. In British Columbia, a claim under ICBC Comprehensive does not affect your premium. In the U.S., a keyed-car claim may raise your rates, and the size of the increase will likely depend on your driving record and your claim history.
Related guides
- Right to Appraisal in Auto Insurance Disputes: What Canadian Drivers Should Know
Read this if you and your insurer do not agree on the amount of your claim.
- Matching Metallic Paint: Why Good Body Shops Blend More Than Colour
Read this before a shop repaints a keyed panel on a car with metallic paint.
Key Takeaways
- Before you decide, ask your insurer or broker how soon your policy wants a vandalism loss reported and how a vandalism claim counts at your renewal.
- If you pay the shop yourself, keep the photos, the police report number and the paid repair invoice together.
- Choose a car scratch repair shop near you to repair the keyed panels, whether you claim or pay yourself.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does full coverage cover a keyed car?
Only if your policy includes comprehensive cover, or in Canada specified perils or all perils cover. Check the cover names on your policy, not the words "full coverage". In Canada, mandatory auto insurance is only the minimum that every owner must buy, and these covers are among the additional coverages available. Ask your insurer or broker which covers your own policy lists.
How do I report a keyed car to the police in British Columbia?
Vancouver drivers file the report online with the Vancouver Police Department. Everywhere else in the province, phone the local police or the RCMP and report the vandalism. Keep the police file number that you get, because ICBC needs it when you open your vandalism claim.
Can I buff out a key scratch myself?
You likely can, if the key did not break through the clear coat: a scratch that stays in that top layer can be buffed out without a shop. A scratch that cuts down to bare metal is a different case, because exposed metal can rust and cause more damage later.
Can you press charges if someone keyed your car?
In Canada, wilfully damaging property is mischief under section 430 of the Criminal Code. The maximum penalty depends on the value of the property: up to 10 years in prison above CAD 5,000, and up to 2 years at CAD 5,000 or less, or a summary conviction offence in each case. Give the police any name or witness that you have, and confirm the next steps with them. In the U.S., ask your local police.
Did this post answer your question?
Find trusted Car Scratch Repair shops near you
Compare local independent shops that offer Car Scratch Repair and choose the right fit for your vehicle.
Find Car Scratch Repair shopsShare or ask AI about this article
Continue the conversation or send this guide to someone who needs it.
Related guides
Will a Car Scratch Rust? What Makes It Rust and What to Do
A car scratch can rust once it cuts through the primer to the metal. See what still covers the metal, what affects how soon it rusts and what to do next.
Scratches Behind Your Car Door Handles: Why They Happen and How to Fix Them
Why fingers, keys and rings scratch the cup behind your car door handle, how to test the depth, polish light marks by hand and stop them coming back.
Do Black Cars Scratch More Easily? Why Scratches Show More on Dark Paint
Black cars do not scratch more easily. Learn why scratches and swirl marks show more on dark paint, and how to wash and fix a black finish.