Does Hail Damage Lower Your Car's Value? Repair or Sell As Is
Does hail damage lower your car's value?
It can. In the U.S., AAA advises that small hail dents left unrepaired can lower a car's resale value. To choose between a repair and a sale as is, compare a written repair estimate with written offers for the car with the dents still in place.
Sources for this guide
Sources, as of 2026: AAA, the Insurance Bureau of Canada, the Louisiana Legislature (R.S. 32:702), the Colorado General Assembly (2017 act HB 17-1205), the U.S. Department of Justice NMVTIS consumer page, the Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner, the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, OMVIC (Ontario), AMVIC (Alberta) and the Vehicle Sales Authority of BC. No official source gives a percent or dollar figure for how much hail lowers a car's value.
Repair before you sell, or sell as is: what decides it
Did you find what you were looking for?
Hail-damage title brands in the U.S.: the Louisiana rule
Under Louisiana law, a car whose cosmetic hail damage (glass, paint and dents, for example) costs 75% or more of its market value to repair is not deemed a total loss and is not salvaged. Its title gets a hail-damage brand instead. With sample values, USD 9,300 of hail repairs on a car with a USD 12,000 market value gives USD 9,300 ÷ USD 12,000 = 77.5%, so the brand applies.
What a dealer must disclose about past damage in Ontario, Alberta and BC
| Province | Repair-cost line | Other history the dealer must disclose |
|---|---|---|
| Ontario | Total repair cost of damage from an incident, if known, when it was over CAD 3,000 | Any class of irreparable, salvage or rebuilt under provincial law, and the last class |
| Alberta | Repairs over CAD 3,000, parts and labour included, from an incident or collision, in writing before the sale | Any declaration as a salvage or non-repairable vehicle, in Alberta or the equivalent elsewhere |
| British Columbia | Damage that cost more than CAD 2,000 to repair, in the written sales agreement | Anything that would be material to the buyer's decision to buy |
Diminished value: the price gap after a repair
In the U.S., Washington State's insurance regulator defines diminished value for a car repaired after an accident: it is how much less the car is worth on the market after the repair than it was worth, undamaged, before the accident. An insurer there does not pay diminished value automatically. The owner must prove that the car's market value fell even after the repair.
Related guides
- Does an Accident Lower Your Car's Resale Value in Canada?
How body damage and repair records come up when you sell a car after an accident.
- How to Check a Used Car's History and Recalls by VIN
How to look up a car's past by its VIN before you buy it.
- How to Inspect a Rebuilt Salvage Car for Safety and Structural Integrity
What to check on a car with a salvage or rebuilt history before you buy it.
Key Takeaways
- Keep the hail repair estimate, the final invoice and any letters from your insurer together, so a buyer can see what was repaired.
- In the U.S., title rules for hail differ by state, so check the rules of the state where the car is titled before you buy or sell.
- Ask a hail damage repair shop for a written estimate that lists each panel and its repair method, before you set a price for the car.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who pays a diminished value claim?
In Washington State, it is typically the insurer of the at-fault party, not your own insurer. Across the U.S., state laws differ on first-party claims, made to your own insurer, and third-party claims, made to the insurer of another party. Ask your state insurance department how the rules apply to your car.
Does car insurance cover hail damage in Canada?
Yes, if your policy has optional comprehensive coverage, which protects the car against common perils such as fire, high winds and hail. Not every vehicle policy in Canada covers hail damage, so confirm with your insurance representative that your policy includes that coverage.
Does a total loss mean my car is worthless?
No. In the U.S., an insurer's total-loss decision does not by itself mean that the car was destroyed or has no value. But cars with significant damage often get a "junk" or "salvage" brand on the title, so check the title before you buy or sell such a car.
Is a hail-damaged car a salvage vehicle in Colorado?
Not because of the hail damage, under a 2017 Colorado act. That act left hail damage out of the part of the salvage vehicle definition that covers a vehicle damaged by collision, fire, flood, accident, trespass or another occurrence. Ask the Colorado motor vehicle agency for the current title rules before you buy or sell a car there.
How do I check a used car's title for a hail or salvage brand?
In the U.S., ask the motor vehicle agency of the state that issued the title for the actual state title record. A hail-damage brand, such as the Louisiana one, is part of a branded title, so the title record is the place to see it. Do this before you buy a car with hail repairs.
Did this post answer your question?
Find trusted Hail Damage Repair shops near you
Compare local independent shops that offer Hail Damage Repair and choose the right fit for your vehicle.
Find Hail Damage Repair shopsShare or ask AI about this article
Continue the conversation or send this guide to someone who needs it.
Related guides
What Does Hail Damage Look Like on a Car? How to Check Yours
Learn what hail damage looks like on a car, where to look first, how to check your own car after a storm, and how to spot old hail repairs on a used car.
How Long Do You Have to File a Hail Damage Claim on Your Car?
See the hail claim time limits in Ontario and B.C., a dated example, what the Texas regulator advises, and the Ontario steps that keep a claim on time.
When Is Hail Season? What Drivers in Canada and the U.S. Should Expect
Hail season months for Calgary, Alberta, the Prairies, Colorado and Texas, the peak month, and how to protect your car and claim hail damage.